Don’t feel like baking? No worries! Bring the taste of Lancaster County right to your table with an already baked shoofly pie or some of our Zookies Molasses Cookies.

Stack of Shoofly Whoopie Pies - Golden Barrel
Shoofly Whoopie Pies (pack of 3)
Get the taste of this popular Lancaster County Pennsylvania Dutch treat in a unique whoopie pie form. Comes as a pack of 3. Ingredients: Shortening, Brown Sugar, Molasses, Eggs, Vanilla, Maple Extract, Baking Soda, Salt, Flour. Filling: Shortening, Margarine, Butter Milk, Flour, 6X Sugar, Vanilla, Milk. Contains Wheat, Egg, and Milk.
$3.00 Add to cart
Already Made Shoofly Pie
Shoofly Pies (Already Made)
Already made wet bottom shoofly pies made by a local Lancaster County bakery. Pies are 9'' deep dish.
not rated $7.49 Add to cart
Zookies Molasses Cookies on a Plate
Zookies Molasses Cookies
For when you don't quite feel like baking, these Old Fashioned Soft Molasses Cookies are the perfect treat for that homemade taste of Lancaster County shipped right to your door. Sold by the dozen.
$4.49 Add to cart