Back to Molasses

Zookies Molasses Cookies

Rated 4.00 out of 5 based on 2 customer ratings
(3 customer reviews)

$4.49

For when you don’t quite feel like baking, these Old Fashioned Soft Molasses Cookies are the perfect treat for that homemade taste of Lancaster County shipped right to your door.

Sold by the dozen.

SKU: ZOOKCOOK12 Categories: ,

Additional information

Weight 1 lbs
Dimensions 9 × 5.5 × 3.25 in

3 reviews for Zookies Molasses Cookies

  1. Avatar

    Terry in TX (verified owner)

    I love a chewy molasses cookie, but I’ve never had a recipe that resulted in one as good as I’ve had at some New England bakeries. Now that I am living in Texas, I never even see molasses cookies, so I have really been missing that rich, chewy yumminess that you only get from real molasses. Recently I stumbled across the Golden Barrel website while searching for new recipe to try again making my own. When I saw these, I had to order some. The photograph looked so delicious, the price was very reasonable, and I am familiar with the reputation of Amish quality, so I had really high expectations for these cookies. Unfortunately, I was disappointed. They were okay, they just were not especially flavorful. They were a little dry as well, kind of cake-like. Because they are soft, they were not good for dunking which is how I eat a cookie that is less than I’d hoped. Imagine trying to dunk a muffin crown into your coffee– yep, it instantly fell apart and into my cup of coffee with a plop. 🙂 My search continues…

  2. Avatar
    Rated 5 out of 5

    sshelly (verified owner)

    I ordered a dozen of these cookies earlier this year, and was very impressed on how good they are. After writing this review, I’m going to order 2 dozen.
    Great products at Golden Barrel!!

  3. Avatar
    Rated 3 out of 5

    Lenora R Hatch (verified owner)

    I ordered some recently along with shoofly whoopie pies. The cookies arrived stuck together and couldn’t be separated neatly. I prefer a stronger molasses taste. They do have a bit of a cake texture when I expected something a little denser. They were nice cookies, just not how I prefer molasses cookies.

    Also didn’t like the packing peanuts. Styrofoam is bad for the environment.

Add a review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *