Peanut Butter Coconut Oil Dog Treats

posted in: Recipes | 80

These dog treats are super easy to make and only have three ingredients in them. Those ingredients are not only tasty but they’re also healthful for your pet. Your furry friend is sure to gobble these dog treats up!

Using Golden Barrel Coconut Oil to make Dog Treats

We have a new addition to our family, as of last Tuesday. Her name is Penny.

Penny the Cockapoo with Long Hair

When we got our two year old cockapoo, her fur was long and matted. A couple days later, she got cleaned up with a fresh cut. I think she lost 10 lbs in the process!

Penny the Cockapoo with short hair

While I personally like a dog with a longer coat, I want it to be healthy so I researched some ways to promote shine in dogs’ fur. You know what was one of the first ingredients I read about? Coconut oil. I should have figured. I know it does wonders for human skin and hair so it came as no surprise to read the benefits of using it on your pooch. Coconut oil can be applied topically for a deep conditioning treatment (great for dry skin!) or ingested to promote health from within. Here are just a few of the benefits of coconut oil for your dog:

Benefits of Coconut Oil for Dogs

I definitely want these benefits for our Penny so I made these yummy treats for her that includes Golden Barrel Coconut Oil, peanut butter and cinnamon. Why cinnamon? Because cinnamon has anti-inflammatory properties as well as the ability to slow or stop bacterial growth. It helps regulate blood sugar and assists with insulin resistance. Plus it’s just tasty!

Ingredients to make Dog treats

You simply melt the coconut oil and peanut butter in a double boiler on the stove, add the cinnamon, mixing everything together until combined and smooth.

Adding ingredients to make healthy dog treats

Melted Peanut Butter and Coconut Oil

Pour the mix into silicone trays and freeze until set. Seriously, this recipe couldn’t be easier!

Peanut Butter and Coconut Oil Dog Treats

Pop them out of the trays and store in a covered dish in the refrigerator.

Cinnamon, peanut butter, coconut oil Dog Treats

Penny totally loves these treats! And my boys love giving them to her. 😉

dog8

So do you have a furry friend who would enjoy these coconut oil dog treats? It’ll take you all of 10 minutes to whip up a batch. Try it today!

Cinnamon, peanut butter, coconut oil dog treats

Using Golden Barrel Coconut Oil to make Dog Treats
Peanut Butter Coconut Oil Dog Treats
Print Recipe
Servings
3 dozen
Servings
3 dozen
Using Golden Barrel Coconut Oil to make Dog Treats
Peanut Butter Coconut Oil Dog Treats
Print Recipe
Servings
3 dozen
Servings
3 dozen
Ingredients
Servings: dozen
Instructions
  1. Add all ingredients to a bowl (double boiler) over pot on stove. Stir until melted and combined.
  2. Using a tablespoon, pour mixture into silicone baking trays and place in freezer until set.
  3. Store treats in refrigerator.
Share this Recipe

Also try our other recipe: Dog Treats made with Coconut Oil and Blackstrap Molasses.

Kat Hertzler
Kat is a mother of three boys who loves to bake and enjoys all things DIY. She has been blogging since 2010 featuring recipes and home design projects. Some of her home projects have been featured in Country Living and This Old House magazine, as well as many other prominent DIY blogs and websites.

80 Responses

  1. L. Moralle

    This treat should be good for humans also, rightL?

  2. Any thoughts on what to use instead of silicone trays?

    • Kat Hertzler

      You could try them in mini muffin pans. Might be a little difficult to “pop them out” but I’m sure if you slide a thin knife blade around the perimeter, they should come out. Hope that helps!

    • I used regular ice cube trays and only filled 3/4. Froze. Twisted like you do ice cube. Worked great.

    • Lisa Cacciolfi

      I got mine at ikea

  3. How long will they last in the fridge?

    • Kat Hertzler

      They’ll last a long time, since coconut oil has a very stable shelf life, as does peanut butter. In other words, they really can’t “go bad” and as long as you keep them in the fridge, they’ll stay in a solid form. Just don’t set them out on the counter in this hot weather and you’ll be good to go! 😉

  4. I do not see the amount of each ingredients to use. Could someone email them to

    Judy

  5. My mother has two toy breads “dots” are a perfect treat. She lets the mixture cool a bit so it starts to thicken. Using a cookie sheet and wax paper she makes “dots” with a teaspoon measure. It works great.

  6. jane mushenheim

    nice! sprayed coconut baking spray in plastic ice cube tray…poured in froza,1ish hr. cut apart ..ez. all my pups,loved em thx!

  7. Morgan Atwell

    I just made these can’t wait to see what my two dogs think of them.

  8. So excited to try this!

  9. What could I use in stead of the cinnamon?

    • Kat Hertzler

      Just omit the cinnamon altogether if it’s something you don’t have/want to add to it. It’ll turn out the same way. Hope you try making them!

  10. How often can you give you dog these treats

    • Kat Hertzler

      Hi, Heidi,
      I give my dog several a day.

      • jocelyn marie

        hi my name is Jocelyn and I wanted to ask if these treats are ok for my moms dog she has low blood suger and has to have honey sometimes so is this recipe ok to add about a teaspoon of honey into it as well as the peanut butter ,coconut oil and cinnamon will it come out the same please!!!! email me back to let me know at

        smokeybabe4@gmail.com

        I would love to hear from u with some information on some good ways to keep my dogs blood suger up so she doesn’t have seziures please!!! and thank u

        • Mitch Hertzler
          Mitch Hertzler

          Hi Jocelyn,
          Thanks for your interest in our recipe. In response to your questions, neither our company or Kat, the blogger and recipe developer, are experts in dog nutrition. We really cannot say how this recipe or adding other ingredients would affect your dogs blood pressure. I would recommend asking a veterinarian or other pet nutritionist. It is possible that the recipe itself would work by adding some honey or other sweetener but that may be something you would have to experiment with. Hope that helps.

    • Lisa Cacciolfi

      Yes my dogs get 2 a day

  11. Coconut is a natural laxative for humans. Is it the same for amimals? If it is, several a day makes me worry that he may have an accident in the house.

    • Kat Hertzler

      I didn’t have any trouble with my cockapoo, but that’s not to say it works the same with all dogs. If your dog has a sensitive stomach, start slowly, perhaps with a half size. Work your way up! It’s a tasty treat that’s very beneficial for your furry friend!

    • My dog first started getting the runs on a tablespoon of coconut oil. He’s a 6.7kg Pom. I brought the amount down to and that sorted things for him. It could be a bit of trial and error. As long as it doesn’t last for days and he gets plenty of water, a day or two of the runs won’t do them much harm.

  12. I wasn’t sure when I first saw the recipe, gave it a try, so easy to make and my dogs love them. A real smart way to give them coconut oil! As we know, it’s so good for them, (and the dogs owners). Thank you so much for putting this out there!

  13. I’m going to make those for my baby girl-she loves her peanut butter!

  14. Sue Norris

    I saw the same recipe with a different source that recommended starting slowly with coconut oil to allow dogs to become accustomed to it. Wondered how you (or others) felt about this and if too much for a small dog could cause problems. This article recommended adapting the recipe to the size of the dog: 1 teaspoon coconut oil per 10 lb. of body weight or 1 tablespoon for 30 lbs., etc. It also said to start with 1/4 dose of coconut oil and increase to full dose over a few weeks. Would you think this means to start with 1 T. for the whole batch (1 c. peanut butter) for a 30 pound dog? Has anyone had problems in giving the 1 c. PB/1c. coconut oil formula to a small dog?

    • Kat Hertzler

      Penny (my cockapoo) is a small dog and she does fine with these treats. Maybe if your dog has a delicate stomach, start slowly, but if he/she is healthy, there shouldn’t be a problem giving it a few treats a day. If you’re concerned, just start with one treat. Hope that helps!

  15. Annabel E.

    Will the coconut oil lose it beneficial properties if you microwave everything together instead of using double boiler?

  16. Kat, Do you have a great recipe like this for cats? They really need the coconut oil but they are finicky, duh, & will not eat their food, wet or dry, if I add it. Thanx for this recipe!

    • Kat Hertzler

      Hi Patricia,
      I’d imagine the same recipe could be used for cats as well. Maybe with the peanut butter mixed in, they won’t fuss at the coconut oil. Fingers crossed!

    • Instead of coconut oil for cats, give them salmon oil. It’ll do the same thing for their skin and coat and also comes in oderless. I don’t use the oderless and give it to my dogs and cats and haven’t noticed any weird oders.

  17. Can you post where you purchased the heart mold? Are these small? I have very small Maltese. 4′ and 8′.

    • Kat Hertzler

      Hi Barb,
      I actually got the molds at a thrift store but I’m sure there are similar ones on Amazon. And yes, they are small sized hearts.

  18. I made these for my dog & he absolutely loves them! And sooooo easy to make! Thank you!

  19. I make these for my 14 year old Labrador retriever and hide some of her meds in them. She loooves them and it makes it so much easier to get her to take her medicine twice per day. I also love the health benefits that these treats provide, since our girl is geriatric and has quite a list of health issues.

    P.s. I purchased our silicone dog treat trays from Amazon and just microwave the ingredients instead of melting on the stove. I otherwise follow the recipe exactly as posted and my dog has never had any issues with the full dosage of coconut oil.

  20. I make these with brewers yeast for additional benefits. I also let them set up in the refrigerator instead of the freezer and make it in my BlenTech. My dogs love them as a dessert! I picked up a Kong tray at a thrift store for 50 cents as well as silicone ice trays.

  21. Thank you for sharing your recipe! I am getting ready to make a second batch for my three fur babies – they all love them. I took Marylee’s recommendation and added brewer’s yeast. Even my husband thought they were tasty! Thanks again!

  22. Hi there just wondering if you use the coconut oil in a more solid form or melted in oil?

  23. I was wondering if you were to microwave it, how long would you put it in there?

  24. Careful with the cinnamon. It’s not recomended to give to dogs. Just fyi.?

  25. Great recipe. Make sure to mention the danger of xylitol in some peanut butters. It is toxic to dogs. Thanks!

  26. I’ve tried making these treats twice now but I can’t get the treats to harden. They’ve been in the fridge for days and they still have no form.

    • Kat Hertzler

      You’re using coconut oil, correct? Because coconut oil has a melting point of 76 degrees, it will harden when put in the fridge. So I’m not sure exactly what’s going on. I always stick mine in the freezer for a while, then store them in the fridge. Maybe try that. Hope you can get it to work!

      • When measuring the coconut oil do you use it in its solid form or melted in liquid form ?

  27. I just finish making these and my dogs (4) schnauzer just love them. They are easy, simple, and great ingredients.
    I don’t like store bought snacks for them. They also like peanut butter cookies that I make with low sodium veg broth, Thanks for a great treat.
    Spokane, WA

  28. Thank you for the recipe! I tried it today. My puppy, Lucy, loved them. I added a couple squeezes of honey. So easy and she loved them. Thanks again!

  29. Do you recommend a particular brand or type of peanut butter when making these treats for dogs? Does one type work better (smooth or crunchy) for this recipe? What brand do you recommend? Thanks!

  30. Tara Jensen

    I made these super easy, gave them to my dogs and they were unsure at first cause well its something new, once they smelled the peanut butter and tasted it they gobbled it up. One of u asked about what kind of peanut butter I read online that the best kind of peanut butter for dogs is either organic or dry unsaltred peanut butter. What else can I use forflavor?? Can I add like a bit of beef broth or will it not harden like it should?? I’m thinking of adding some honey in there I don’t wanna make it to sweet though. Can I add oatmeal??

  31. Tara Jensen

    Would it also work out if I put like pureed sweet potatoes or instant potatoes or pumpkin stuff like that??

  32. I once heard that PB could be toxic to dogs. What kind of PB do you recommend?

    • Peanut butter is very good for dogs. If it has sweeteners or xylitol it’s toxic for dogs. When I use peanut butter for dog treats I get the all natural peanut butter. Only ingredient is peanuts. It’s like $3 at most grocery stores.

  33. How many would you say a 230 pound mastiff puppy could have a day?

    • Coconut oil is 1 tbsp. Per 30 lbs. so a 230 lb dog could have up to 7.5 tbsp. a day. I was trying to figure out the same for my 90 lb. pit. I’m thinking maybe it depends how many treats you got out of the 1 cup coconut oil..? I used 237 grams/75 mold spots so a little over 3 grams coconut oil/treat. Google said 14 grams/tbsp. CHECK my math as I’m just thinking myself…. maybe something like that to figure out ?

  34. Michelle valle

    Any way to use something in the receipt that will keep it hard when at room temperature? I would like to put these out for customers to give to their dogs as a treat after their groom

  35. Michelle valle

    Is there anything you can add to this that is dog safe that will keep it solid at room temperature?

  36. I just realized the peanut butter I used has sugar..
    I already gave my dog a treat, do you think he will be alright?

  37. Lisa & Lucy Shannon

    I have a 13lb. Skorkie her name is Lucy, and she loves the coconut oil right out of the jar or I might melt some in the microwave for 10 to 15 seconds and pour over her dry dog food. I was excited to see your recipe, and tried it right away!!! Needless to say “Lucy is a huge fan”. I too omitted the cinnamon as I’ve read it’s toxic, and sprinkled some oats in prior to pouring into the molds. There adorable little treats, and Lucy can give them out at holiday’s to her puppy friends. ?? Thanks so much!!!

  38. Can you use any coconut oil and peanut butter, or do you have to use a specific brand?

  39. Hi- can gelatin be added to these? Would it work?

  40. Do I have to melt the PB and Coconut oil together or could I just mix then 2 ingredients?

  41. These treats are so easy to make. The only problem is, they start to melt almost immediately…. even after leaving out for 3 minutes. I use organic coconut oil and Organic peanut butter. Am I doing anything wrong? I see treats in dog stores that sit out and they never are greasy or melt to the touch like these. Any suggestions?

  42. How much yeast can be added to the recipe, excited to make for my babies

  43. Your page won’t let me pin your recipe 🙁 It says that this page does not allow pins.

    • Mitch Hertzler
      Mitch Hertzler

      Hi Jana,
      Our site stopped allowing pins sometime over the last week most likely due to an updated plugin conflict. I am working to try and resolve it. Thanks for letting us know and sorry for the inconvenience.

  44. Can I use crunchy peanut butter in place of creamy?

  45. Great idea….just made so looking forward to trying on the boxer n cavoodle. ..we are in transistion of moving away from kibble biscuits n supermarket treats after watching the documentary PET FOOLED….brilliant insight into consumers being fooled by the rubbish in bags…..RAW here we come…..

Leave a Reply